NGHIÊN CỨU VỀ NĂM VIỆC CỦA ĐẠI THIÊN
Thích Hạnh Bình

PHỤ LỤC 1
(Tải xuống font chữ cần thiết để xem chú thích Pali trong sách này)  
KathŒvatthu

II.1

1. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Atthi Arahato rŒgo kŒmarŒgo kŒmarŒgapariyu  hŒnaµ kŒmaragasa??ojanaµ kŒmogho kŒmayogo kŒmacchadan´varaöan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe-

-N’atthi Arahato rŒgo kŒmarŒgo kŒmarŒgapariyu  hŒnaµ kŒmarŒgasa??ojanaµ kŒmogho kŒmayogo kŒmacchadan´varaöan ti ?

-îmantŒ

-Ha?ci n’atthi Arahato rŒgo kŒmarŒgo kŒmarŒgapariyu  hŒnaµ kŒmarŒgasa??ojanaµ kŒmogho kŒmayogo kŒmacchadan´varaöan, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti.”

 

2. Atthi puthujjanassa asucisukkavisa  hi, atthi tassa rŒgo kŒmarŒgo kŒmarŒgapariyu  hŒnaµ kŒmaragasa??ojanaµ kŒmogho kŒmayogo kŒmacchadan´varaöan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  hi, atthi tassa rŒgo kŒmarŒgo kŒmarŒgapariyu  hŒnaµ  –pe–  kŒmacchadan´varaöan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

-Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  hi, n’atthi tassa rŒgo kŒmarŒgo kŒmarŒgapariyu  hŒnaµ  –pe–  kŒmacchadan´varaöan ti ?

-îmantŒ

-Atthi puthujjanassa asucisukkavisa  hi, n’atthi tassa rŒgo kŒmarŒgo kŒmarŒgapariyu  hŒnaµ  –pe–  kŒmacchadan´varaöan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

 

3. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Ken’atthenŒti ?[1] Handa hi MŒrakŒyikŒ devatŒ Arahato asucisukkavisa  hiµ[2] upasaµharant´ti.

- MŒrakŒyikŒ devatŒ Arahato asucisukkavisa  hiµ upasaµharant´ti ?

- îmantŒ.

- Atthi MŒrakŒyikŒnaµ devatŒnaµ Arahato asucisukkavisa  hiµ upasaµharant´ti ?

- Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

- N’atthi MŒrakŒyikŒnaµ devatŒnaµ asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

- îmantŒ.

- Ha?ci n’atthi MŒrakŒyikŒnaµ devatŒnaµ asucisukkavisa  hi, no vata re vattabbe “MŒrakŒyikŒnaµ devatŒnaµ Arahato asucisukkavisa  hiµ upasaµharant´ti”.

 

4. MŒrakŒyikŒ devatŒ Arahato asucisukkavisa  hiµ upasaµharant´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- MŒrakŒyikŒ devatŒ attano asucisukkavisa  hiµ upasaµharanti, a??esaµ asucisukkavisa  hiµ upasaµharanti, tassa asucisukkavisa  hiµ upasaµharant´ti ?

- Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

- MŒrakŒyikŒ devatŒ n’ev’attano na a??esaµ na tassa asucisukkavisa  hiµ upasaµharant´ti ?

- îmantŒ.

- Ha?ci MŒrakŒyikŒ devatŒ n’ev’[3] attano na a??esaµ na tassa asucisukkavisa  hiµ upasaµharanti, no vata re vattabbe “MŒrakŒyikŒ devatŒ Arahato asucisukkavisa  hiµ upasaµharant´ti”.

 

5. MŒrakŒyikŒ devatŒ Arahato asucisukkavisa  hiµ upasaµharant´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Lomakupehi upasaµharant´ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

-MŒrakŒyikŒ devatŒ Arahato asucisukkavisa  hiµ upasaµharant´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-KiµkŒraöŒ ti ? Handa hi vimatiµ gŒhayissŒmŒti[4].

Atthi Arahato vimat´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Atthi Arahato Satthari vimat´ti, Dhamme vimat´ti, Saµghe vimat´ti, sikkhŒya vimat´ti, pubbante vimat´ti, aparante vimat´ti, pubbantŒparante vimat´ti, idappaccayatŒpa iccasamupannesu dhammesu vimat´ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

-N’atthi Arahato Satthari vimat´ti, Dhamme vimat´ti, Saµghe vimat´ti, sikkhŒya vimat´ti, pubbante vimat´ti, aparante vimat´ti, pubbantŒparante vimat´ti, idappaccayatŒpa iccasamupannesu dhammesu vimat´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Ha?ci n’atthi Arahato Satthari vimat´ti–pe–idappaccayatŒpa iccasamupannesu dhammesu vimati, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato vimat´ti.”

 

6. Atthi puthujjanassa vimati, atthi tassa Satthari vimat´ti –pe– idappaccayatŒpa iccasamupannesu dhammesu vimat´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Atthi Arahato vimat´ti, atthi tassa Satthari vimat´ti –pe– idappaccayatŒpa iccasamupannesu dhammesu vimat´ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

-Atthi Arahato vimat´ti, n’atthi tassa Satthari vimat´ti –pe– idappaccayatŒpa iccasamupannesu dhammesu vimat´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

Atthi puthujjanassa vimati, n’atthi tassa Satthari vimat´ti –pe– idappaccayatŒpa iccasamupannesu dhammesu vimat´ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

7. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Arahato asucisukkavisa  hi kissa nissando ti ? AsitapitakhŒyitasŒyitassa nissando ti.

-Arahato asucisukkavisa  hi asitapitakhŒyitasŒyitassa[5] nissando ti.

-îmantŒ.

-Ye keci asanti, pivanti, khŒyanti, sŒyanti, sabbesa??eva atthi asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

-Ye keci asanti, pivanti, khŒyanti, sŒyanti, sabbesa??eva atthi asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ

-DŒrakŒ asanti, pivanti, khŒyanti, sŒyanti, atthi dŒrakŒnaµ asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

-Paö¶kŒ asanti, pivanti, khŒyanti, sŒyanti, sabbesa??eva atthi paö¶akŒnaµ asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

-DevŒ asanti, pivanti, khŒyanti, sŒyanti, sabbesa??eva atthi devatŒnaµ asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

 

8. Arahato asucisukkavisa  hi asitapitakhŒyitasŒyitassa nissando ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Atthi tassa Œsayo ti ?

- Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

- Arahato uccŒrapassŒvo asitapitakhŒyitasŒyitassa nissando, atthi tassa Œsayo ti ?

- îmantŒ.

- Arahato asucisukkavisa  hi asitapitakhŒyitasŒyitassa nissando, atthi tassa Œsayo ti ?

- Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

- Arahato asucisukkavisa  hi asitapitakhŒyitasŒyitassa nissando, n’atthi tassa Œsayo ti ?

- îmantŒ.

- Arahato uccŒrapassŒvo asitapitakhŒyitasŒyitassa nissando, n’atthi tassa Œsayo ti ?

- Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

 

9. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-ArahŒ methunaµ dhammaµ pa iseveyya, methunaµ[6] dhammaµ uppŒdeyya, puttasambŒdhasayannaµ ajjhŒvaseyya, kŒsikacandanaµ paccanubhaveyya, mŒlŒgandhavilepanaµ dhŒreyya, jŒtarèparajataµ sŒdiyeyyŒti?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

-Atthi puthujjanassa asucisukkavisa  hi, puthujjano methunaµ dhammaµ pa iseveyya, methunaµ dhammaµ uppŒdeyya  –pe–j Œtarèparajataµ sŒdiyeyyŒti?

-îmantŒ.

-Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  hi, ArahŒ methunaµ dhammaµ uppŒdeyya, methunaµ dhammaµ uppŒdeyya  –pe– jŒtarèparajataµ sŒdiyeyyŒti?

-îmantŒ.

-Atthi puthujjanassa asucisukkavisa  hi, na ca puthujjano methunaµ dhammaµ pa iseveyya, methunaµ dhammaµ uppŒdeyya puttasambŒdhasayannaµ ajjhŒvaseyya, kŒsikacandanaµ paccanubhaveyya, mŒlŒgandhavilepanaµ dhŒreyya, jŒtarèparajataµ sŒdiyeyyŒti?

- Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

 

10. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Nanu Arahato rŒgo pah´no ucchinnamèlo tŒlŒvatthukato anabhŒvaµkato Œyatiµ anuppŒdadhammo ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Ha?ci Arahato rŒgo pah´no ucchinnamèlo tŒlŒvatthukato[7] anabhŒvaµkato Œyatiµ anuppŒdadhammo, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti.”

- Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ

-Nanu Arahato doso pah´no  –pe– moho pah´no, mŒno pah´no, di  hi pah´nŒ, vicikicchŒ , th´naµ pah´nŒ, uddhaccaµ pah´naµ –pe–anottappaµ pah´naµ ucchinnamèlaµ tŒlŒvatthukataµ anabhŒvaµkataµ Œyatiµ anuppŒdadhamman ti?

-îmantŒ

-Ha?ci Arahato anottappaµ pah´naµ ucchinnamèlaµ tŒlŒvatthukataµ anabhŒvaµkataµ Œyatiµ anuppŒdadhammaµ no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti.”

 

11. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Nanu Arahato rŒgappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Ha?ci Arahato rŒgappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti.”

Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Nanu Arahato rŒgappahŒnŒya satipa  hŒnŒ bhŒvitŒ –pe–sammappadhŒnŒ bhŒvitŒ, iddhpadŒ bhŒvitŒ, indriyŒ bhŒvitŒ, balŒ bhŒvitŒ –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Ha?ci Arahato rŒgappahŒnŒya bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti.”

 

12 .Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Nanu Arahato dosappahŒnŒya –pe– mohappappahŒnŒya–pe–anottappappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Ha?ci Arahato anottappappahŒnŒya bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti.”

 

13. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Nanu Arahato v´tarŒgo[8] v´tadoso v´tamoho katakaran´yo ohitabhŒro anuppattasadattho parikkkh´öabhavasa??ojano sammada??Œ vimutto ukkhittapaligho saµkiööaparikho abbuÂhesiko[9] niraggaÂo[10] ariyo pannaddhajo pannabhŒro vis??utto suvijitavijayo, dukkhaµ tassa[11] pari??Œtaµ, samudayo pah´no, nirodho sacchikato, maggo bhŒvito, abhi??eyyaµ abhi??Œtaµ, pari??eyyaµ pari??Œtaµ, pahŒtabbaµ pah´naµ, bhŒvetabbaµ bhŒvitaµ, sachikŒtabbaµ sacchikatan ti?

-îmantŒ.

-Ha?ci Arahato v´tarŒgo v´tadoso v´tamoho katakaran´yo –pe– achikŒtabbaµ sacchikataµ, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti.”

 

14, Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti ? Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi asucisukkavisa  hi, paradhammakusalassa Arahato n’atthi asucisukkavisa  h´ti.

- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi asucisukkavisa  h´ti

-îmantŒ.

- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato atthi asucisukkavisa  h´ti

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato n’atthi asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

- îmantŒ.

- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato n’atthi asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

- Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

 

- 15. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgo pah´no, atthi tassa asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

- îmantŒ.

- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgo pah´no, atthi tassa asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no, moho pah´no–pe–anottappaµ pah´naµ, atthi tassa asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappaµ pah´naµ, atthi tassa asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

16. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ –pe– dosappahŒnŒya –pe– mohappahŒnŒya–pe–anottappappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, atthi tassa asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahŒnŒya, bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, atthi tassa asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

 

17. Sadhammakusalo ArahŒ v´tarŒgo v´tadoso–pe–sacchikŒtabbaµ sacchikataµ, atthi tassa asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Paradhammakusalo ArahŒ v´tarŒgo v´tadoso–pe–sacchikŒtabbaµ sacchikataµ, atthi tassa asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

 

18. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgo pah´no, n’atthi tassa asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgo pah´no, n’atthi tassa asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no –pe–moho pah´no–pe–anottappaµ pah´naµ, n’atthi tassa asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato anottappaµ pah´naµ, n’atthi tassa asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

 

19. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ –pe– dosappahŒnŒya –pe– mohappahŒnŒya –pe– anottappappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, n’atthi tassa asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahŒnŒya bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ n’atthi tassa asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

20. Sadhammakusalo ArahŒ v´tarŒgo v´tadoso–pe–sacchikŒtabbaµ sacchikataµ, n’atthi tassa asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Sadhammakusalo ArahŒ v´tarŒgo v´tadoso v´tamoho –pe– sacchikŒtabbaµ sacchikataµ, n’atthi tassa asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe  –pe–

 

21. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisa  h´ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Anu vuttaµ BhagavatŒ－ “Ye te Bhikkhave bhikkhè puthujjanŒ s´lasampannŒ satisampajŒnŒ[12] niddaµ okkamanti, tesaµ asuci na muccati. Ye pi te Bhikkhave bŒhirakŒ[13] isayo kŒmesu v´tarŒgŒ, tesaµ pi asuci na muccati. A  hŒnaµ etaµ Bhikkhave anavakŒso, yaµ [14]Arahato asuci mucceyyŒti.” Atth’eva suttanto ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Arahato atthi asucisukkavisa  h´ti”

 

22. Na vattabbaµ “Arahato atthi asucisukkavisa  h´ti”

-îmantŒ.

- Anu Arahato c´varapiö¶apŒtasenŒsanagilŒnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhŒraµ pare upasaµhareyyun ti ?

- îmantŒ.

Hi?ci Arahato c´varapiö¶apŒtasenŒsanagilŒnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhŒraµ pare upasaµhareyyuµ, tena vata re vattabbe “Arahato atthi asucisukkavisa  h´ti”

 

23. Arahato c´varapiö¶apŒtasenŒsanagilŒnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhŒraµ pare upasaµhareyyun ti, atthi Arahato parèpahŒro ti.?

-îmantŒ.

- Arahato sotŒpattiphalaµ vŒ sakadŒgŒmiphalaµ vŒ anŒgŒmiphalaµ vŒ arahattaµ vŒ pare upasaµhareyyun ti ?

- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

ParèpahŒrakathŒ.

 

                  ______________________________

 

II. 2
 

1. Atthi Arahato a??Κan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Atthi Arahato avijjŒ avijjogho avijjŒyogo avijjŒnusayo avijjŒpariyu  hŒnaµ avijjŒsa??ojanaµ avijjŒn´varaöan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

-N’atthi Arahato avijjŒ avijjogho avijjŒyogo avijjŒnusayo avijjŒpariyu  hŒnaµ avijjŒsa??ojanaµ avijjŒn´varaöan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Hi?ci  n’atthi Arahato avijjŒ –pe– avijjŒn´varaöaµ, no vata re vattabbe “atthi Arahato a??Œöan ti.”

 

2. Atthi puthujjanassa a??Œöaµ, atthi tassa avijjŒ avijjogho avijjŒyogo avijjŒnusayo avijjŒpariyu  hŒnaµ avijjŒsa??ojanaµ avijjŒn´varaöan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Atthi Arahato a??Œöaµ, atthi tassa avijjŒ avijjogho avijjŒyogo avijjŒnusayo avijjŒpariyu  hŒnaµ avijjŒsa??ojanaµ avijjŒn´varaöan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

3. Atthi Arahato a??Œöaµ, n’atthi tassa avijjŒ –pe– avijjŒn´varaöan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Atthi puthujjanassa a??Œöaµ, n’atthi tassa avijjŒ –pe– avijjŒn´varaöan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

4. Atthi Arahato a??Κan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-ArahŒ a??Œöapakato pŒöaµ haneyya, adinnaµ Œdiyeyya, musŒ bhaöeyya, pisuöaµ bhaöeyya, pharusaµ bhaöeyya, samphappalapeyya, sandhiµ chindeyya, nillopaµ hareyya, ekagŒrikaµ[15] kareyya, paripanthe ti  heyya, paradŒraµ gaccheyya, gŒmaghŒtaµ kareyya, nigamaghŒtaµ kareyyŒti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

- Atthi puthujjanassa a??Œöaµ, puthujjano a??Œöapakato pŒöaµ haneyya, adinnaµ Œdiyeyya –pe– nigamaghŒtaµ kareyyati ?

-îmantŒ.

-Atthi Arahato a??Œöaµ, ArahŒ a??Œöapakato pŒöaµ haneyya, adinnaµ Œdiyeyya –pe– nigamaghŒtaµ kareyyati ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

5. Atthi Arahato a??Œöaµ, na ca ArahŒ a??Œöapakato pŒöaµ haneyya, adinnaµ Œdiyeyya –pe– nigamaghŒtaµ kareyyati ?

-îmantŒ.

- Atthi puthujjanassa a??Œöaµ, na ca puthujjanassa a??Œöapakato pŒöaµ haneyya, adinnaµ Œdiyeyya –pe– nigamaghŒtaµ kareyyati ?

- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

6. Atthi Arahato a??Κan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Atthi Arahato Satthari a??Œöaµ, Dhamme a??Œöaµ, Saµghe a??Œöaµ, sikkhŒya a??Œöaµ, pubbante a??Œöaµ, aparante a??Œöaµ, pubbantŒparante a??Œöaµ, idappaccayatŒpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu a??Œöan ti ?

- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

- N’ atthi Arahato Satthari a??Œöaµ, Dhamme a??Œöaµ, Saµghe a??Œöaµ, sikkhŒya a??Œöaµ, pubbante a??Œöaµ, aparante a??Œöaµ, pubbantŒparante a??Œöaµ, idappaccayatŒpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu a??Œöan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Ha?ci n’ atthi Arahato Satthari a??Œöaµ, Dhamme a??Œöaµ, Saµghe a??Œöaµ –pe– idappaccayatŒpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu a??Œöaµ, no vate re vattabbe “atthi Arahato a??Œöan ti.”

 

7. Atthi puthujjanassa a??Œöaµ, atthi tassa Satthari a??Œöaµ, Dhamme a??Œöaµ, Saµghe a??Œöaµ –pe– idappaccayatŒpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu a??Œöan ti ?

-îmantŒ. 

-Atthi Arahato a??Œöaµ, atthi tassa Satthari a??Œöaµ, Dhamme a??Œöaµ, Saµghe a??Œöaµ –pe– idappaccayatŒpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu a??Œöan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

- Atthi Arahato a??Œöaµ, n’ atthi tassa Satthari a??Œöaµ, Dhamme a??Œöaµ, Saµghe a??Œöaµ –pe– idappaccayatŒpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu a??Œöan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Atthi puthujjanassa a??Œöaµ, n’ atthi tassa Satthari a??Œöaµ, Dhamme a??Œöaµ, Saµghe a??Œöaµ –pe– idappaccayatŒpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu a??Œöan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

8. Atthi puthujjanassa a??Κan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Nanu Arahato rŒgo pah´no ucchinnamèlo tŒlŒvatthukato anabhŒvaµkato Œyatiµ anuppŒdadhammo ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Ha?ci Arahato rŒgo pah´no ucchinnamèlo tŒlŒvatthukato anabhŒvaµkato Œyatiµ anuppŒdadhammo, no vate re vattabbe “atthi Arahato a??Œöan ti.”

- Nanu Arahato doso pah´no –pe– moho pah´no –pe– anottappaµ pah´nam ucchinnamèlaµ tŒlŒvatthukataµ anabhŒvaµkataµ Œyatiµ anuppŒdadhamman ti ?

- îmantŒ.

- Ha?ci Arahato anottappaµ pah´nam ucchinnamèlaµ tŒlŒvatthukataµ anabhŒvaµkataµ Œyatiµ anuppŒdadhammaµ, no vate re vattabbe “atthi Arahato a??Œöan ti.”

 

9. Atthi Arahato a??Κan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Nanu Arahato rŒgappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Ha?ci Arahato rŒgappahŒnŒya bhŒvitŒ, no vate re vattabbe “atthi Arahato a??Œöan ti.”

Atthi Arahato a??Κan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Nanu Arahato dosappahŒnŒya –pe– anottappappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ ti ?

- îmantŒ.

- Ha?ci anottappappahŒnŒya bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, no vate re vattabbe “atthi Arahato a??Œöan ti.”

 

10. Atthi Arahato a??Κan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Nanu ArahŒ v´tarŒgo v´tadoso v´tamoho –pe– sacchikŒtabbaµ sacchikatan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Ha?ci, ArahŒ v´tarŒgo –pe– sacchikŒtabbaµ sacchikataµ, no vate re vattabbe “atthi Arahato a??Œöan ti.”

 

 

11. Atthi Arahato a??Œöan ti ? Sadhammakusalassa Arahato n’ atthi a??Œöan ti.

- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi a??Κan ti ?

- îmantŒ.

-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato n’ atthi a??Œöan ti.

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

12. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgo pah´no, atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

- îmantŒ.

- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgo pah´no, atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no, moho pah´no–pe– anottappappaµ pah´naµ, atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappaµ pah´naµ, atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

13. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato dosappahŒnŒya –pe– anottappappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappaŒnŒya bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

14. Sadhammakusalo ArahŒ v´tarŒgo v´tadoso v´tamoho –pe– sacchikŒtabbaµ sacchikataµ, atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

Paradhammakusalo ArahŒ v´tarŒgo –pe– sacchikŒtabbaµ sacchikataµ, atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

15. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgo pah´no, n’ atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgo pah´no, n’ atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no –pe– anottappappaµ pah´naµ, n’ atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no –pe– anottappappaµ pah´naµ, n’ atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

16. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ –pe–anottappappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe–bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, n’ atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahŒnŒya bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, n’ atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

- Paradhammakusalo ArahŒ v´tarŒgo v´tadoso v´tamoho –pe– sacchikŒtabbaµ sacchikataµ, n’ atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Sadhammakusalo ArahŒ v´tarŒgo –pe– sacchikŒtabbaµ sacchikataµ, n’ atthi tassa a??Œöan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

17. Atthi Arahato a??Κan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Nanu vuttaµ BhagavatŒ－ “JŒnatvŒhaµ[16] Bhikkhave passato ŒsavŒnaµ khayaµ vadŒmi, no ajŒnato no apassato. Ki? ca[17] Bhikkhave jŒnato kiµ passato ŒsavŒnaµ khayo hoti ? Iti rèpaµ, rèpaµ, iti rèpassa samudayo, iti rèpassa atthangamo[18]; iti vedanŒ –pe– iti sa??Œ –pe– iti saµkhŒrŒ –pe– iti vi??Œöaµ, iti  vi??Œöassa samudayo, iti vi??Œöassa atthangamo ti. Evaµ kho Bhikkhave jŒnato evaµ passato ŒsavŒnaµ khayo hot´ti.” Atth’eva suttanto ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Tena hi na vattabbaµ ‘Atthi Arahato a??Œöan ti”

 

18. Atthi Arahato a??Κan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Nanu vuttaµ BhagavatŒ－ “JŒnatvŒhaµ Bhikkhave passato ŒsavŒnaµ khayaµ vadŒmi, no ajŒnato no apassato. Ki? ca Bhikkhave jŒnato kiµ passato ŒsavŒnaµ khayo hoti ? Idaµ dukkhan ti Bhikkhave ajŒnato apassato ŒsavŒnaµ khayo hoti, ayaµ dukkhasamudayo ti jŒnato passato ŒsavŒnaµ khayo hoti, ayaµ dukkhanirodhagŒmin´pa ipadŒ ti jŒnato passato ŒsavŒnaµ khayo hoti. Evaµ kho Bhikkhave jŒnato evaµ passato ŒsavŒnaµ khayo hot´ti.” Atth’eva suttanto ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Tena hi na vattabbaµ ‘Atthi Arahato a??Œöan ti”

 

19. Atthi Arahato a??Κan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

Nanu vuttaµ BhagavatŒ－ “Sabbaµ Bhikkhave anabhijŒnaµ aparijŒnaµ avirŒjayaµ appajahaµ abhabbo dukkhkkhŒyŒya. Sabba? ca kho Bhikkhave abhijŒnaµ parijŒnaµ virŒjayaµ pajahaµ bhabbo dukkhakkhŒyŒyŒti” Atth’eva suttanto ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Tena hi na vattabbaµ ‘Atthi Arahato a??Œöan ti”

 

20. Atthi Arahato a??Κan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Nanu vuttaµ BhagavatŒ－

   “SahŒ v’assa dassanasampadŒya[19]

    Tayas su[20] dhammŒ jahitŒ bhavanti

    SakkŒyadi  hi vicikicchita? ca

    S´labbataµ vŒpi ca vippamutto

    Catèh’ apŒyehi ca vippamutto

    Cha cŒbhi hŒnŒni[21] abhabbo kŒtun ti”.

-Atth’eva suttanto ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato a??Œöan ti” ?

 

21. Atthi Arahato a??Κan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Nanu vuttaµ BhagavatŒ－

-Nanu vuttaµ BhagavatŒ－ “Yasmiµ Bhikkhave samaye ariyasŒvakassa virajaµ v´tamalaµ dhammacakkhuµ udapŒdi, ‘yaµ ki?ci samudayadhammaµ sabban taµ nirodhadhamman ti,’ saha dassanuppŒdŒ Bhikkhave ariyasŒvakassa t´öi sa??ojaöŒni pah´yanti, sakkŒyadi  hi vicikicchŒ s´labbataparŒmŒso ti.” Atth’eva suttanto ti”

-îmantŒ.

Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato a??Œöan ti” ?

 

22. Na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato a??Œöan ti”

-îmantŒ.

-Nanu ArahŒ i  hipurisŒnaµ[22] nŒmagottaµ na jŒneyya, maggŒmaggaµ na jŒneyya, tiöaka  havanappat´naµ[23] nŒmaµ na jŒneyyŒti ?

 

23. ArahŒ i  hipurisŒnaµ nŒmagottaµ na jŒneyya, maggŒmaggaµ na jŒneyya, tiöaka  havanappat´naµ nŒmaµ najŒneyyŒti atthi Arahato a??Œöan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-ArahŒ sotŒpattiphalaµ vŒ sakadŒgŒmiphalaµ vŒgŒmiphalaµ vŒ arahattaµ vŒ na jŒneyyŒti ?

- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

                  

                    A??ŒöakathŒ.

           

            ____________________________________

 

II. 3

 

1. Atthi Arahato kankhΠti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Atthi Arahato vicikicchŒ vicikicchŒpariyu  hŒnaµ vicikicchŒsa??ojanaµ vicikicchŒn´varanan ti ?

- Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

- N’atthi Arahato vicikicchŒ vicikicchŒpariyu  hŒnaµ vicikicchŒsa??ojanaµ vicikicchŒn´varanan ti ?

- îmantŒ.

- Ha?ci n’atthi Arahato vicikicchŒ vicikicchŒpariyu  hŒnaµ vicikicchŒsa??ojanaµ vicikicchŒn´varanaµ, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato kankhŒ ti” ?

 

- 2. Atthi puthujjanassa kankhŒ, atthi tassa vicikicchŒ vicikicchŒpariyu  hŒnaµ vicikicchŒsa??ojanaµ vicikicchŒn´varanan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Atthi Arahato kankhŒ, atthi tassa vicikicchŒ vicikicchŒpariyu  hŒnaµ vicikicchŒsa??ojanaµ vicikicchŒn´varanan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

3.Atthi Arahato kankhŒ, n’atthi tassa vicikicchŒ vicikicchŒpariyu  hŒnaµ vicikicchŒsa??ojanaµ vicikicchŒn´varanan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Atthi puthujjanassa kankhŒ, n’atthi tassa vicikicchŒ vicikicchŒpariyu  hŒnaµ vicikicchŒsa??ojanaµ vicikicchŒn´varanan ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

4. Atthi Arahato kankhΠti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Atthi Arahato Satthari kankhŒ, Dhamme kankhŒ, Saµghe kankhŒ, sikŒya kankhŒ, pubbante kankhŒ, aparante kankhŒ, pubbantŒparante kankhŒ, idappaccayatŒpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu kankhŒ ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

-N’atthi Arahato Satthari kankhŒ, Dhamme kankhŒ, Saµghe kankhŒ, sikŒya kankhŒ, pubbante kankhŒ, aparante kankhŒ, pubbantŒparante kankhŒ, idappaccayatŒpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu kankhŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Ha?ci n’atthi Arahato Satthari kankhŒ, Dhamme kankhŒ, Saµghe kankhŒ –pe– idappaccayatŒpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu kankhŒ, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato kankhŒ ti” 

 

5. Atthi puthujjanassa kankhŒ, atthi tassa Satthari kankhŒ, Dhamme kankhŒ, Saµghe kankhŒ –pe–idappaccayatŒpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu kankhŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Atthi Arahato kankhŒ, atthi tassa Satthari kankhŒ, Dhamme kankhŒ, Saµghe kankhŒ –pe– idappaccayatŒpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu kankhŒ ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

- Atthi Arahato kankhŒ, n’atthi tassa Satthari kankhŒ, Dhamme kankhŒ, Saµghe kankhŒ –pe– idappaccayatŒpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu kankhŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Atthi puthujjanassa kankhŒ, n’atthi tassa Satthari kankhŒ, Dhamme kankhŒ, Saµghe kankhŒ –pe– idappaccayatŒpa iccasamuppannesu dhammesu kankhŒ ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

6. Atthi Arahato kankhΠti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Nanu Arahato rŒgo pah´no ucchinnamèlo tŒlŒvatthukato anabhavaµkato Œyatiµ anuppŒdadhamma, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato kankhŒ ti” 

-Nanu Arahato doso pah´no –pe– moho pah´no –pe– anottappaµ pah´naµ ucchinnamèlaµ tŒlŒvatthukataµ anabhŒvaµkataµ Œyatiµ anuppŒdadhamman ti ? 

-îmantŒ.

- Ha?ci Arahato anottappaµ pah´naµ ucchinnamèlaµ tŒlŒvatthukataµ anabhŒvaµkataµ Œyatiµ anuppŒdadhammaµ, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato kankhŒ ti.”

 

7. Atthi Arahato kankhΠti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Nanu Arahato rŒgappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Ha?ci Arahato rŒgappahŒnŒya bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato kankhŒ ti.”

-Atthi Arahato kankhΠti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Nanu Arahato dosoppahŒnŒya –pe– anottappappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Ha?ci anottappappahŒnŒya bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato kankhŒ ti.”

 

8. Atthi Arahato kankhΠti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Nanu ArahŒ v´tarŒgo v´tadoso v´tamoho –pe– sacchikŒtabbaµ sacchikatan ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Ha?ci ArahŒ v´tarŒgo v´tadoso v´tamoho –pe– sacchikŒtabbaµ sacchikataµ, no vata re vattabbe “Atthi Arahato kankhŒ ti.”

 

9. Atthi Arahato kankhŒ ti ? Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi kankhŒ, Paradhammakusalassa Arahato n’atthi kankhŒ ti.

-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi kankhΠti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato atthi kankhΠti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

Paradhammakusalassa Arahato n’atthi kankhŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato n’atthi kankhŒ ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

10. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgo pah´no, atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgo pah´no, atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no, moho pah´no –pe– anottappaµ pah´naµ atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappaµ pah´naµ atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

11. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato dosappahŒnŒya –pe– anottappappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahŒnŒya bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

12. Sadhammakusalo ArahŒ v´tarŒgo v´tadoso v´tamoho –pe– sacchikŒtabbaµ sacchikataµ, atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Paradhammakusalo ArahŒ v´tarŒgo –pe– sacchikŒtabbaµ sacchikataµ, atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

13. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgo pah´no, n’atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgo pah´no, n’atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

-Paradhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no –pe– anottappaµ pah´naµ, n’atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pah´no –pe– anottappaµ pah´naµ, n’atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

14. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rŒgappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ–pe–anottappappahŒnŒya maggo bhŒvito –pe– bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, n’atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahŒnŒya bojjhangŒ bhŒvitŒ, n’atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

-Paradhammakusalo ArahŒ v´tarŒgo v´tarŒgo v´tadoso v´tamoho–pe– sacchikŒtabbaµ sacchikataµ, n’atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Sadhammakusalo ArahŒ v´tarŒgo –pe– sacchikŒtabbaµ sacchikataµ, n’atthi tassa kankhŒ ti ?

-Na h’evaµ vattabbe –pe–

 

15. Atthi Arahato kankhΠti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Nanu vuttaµ BhagavatŒ－ “JŒnatvŒhaµ Bhikkhave passato ŒsavŒnaµ khayaµ vadŒmi, no ajŒnato no apassato. Ki? ca Bhikkhave jŒnato kiµ passato ŒsavŒnaµ khayo hoti ? Iti rèpaµ, iti rèpassa samudaya, iti rèpassa atthangamo; iti vedanŒ –pe– iti sa??Œ –pe– iti saµkhŒrŒ –pe– iti vi??Œnaµ, iti vi??Œnassa samudayo, iti vi??Œnassa atthangamo ti. Evaµ kho Bhikkhave jŒnato evaµ passato ŒsavŒnaµ khayo hot´ti.” Atth’eva suttanto ti ?

- îmantŒ.

- Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato kankhŒ ti”

 

16. Atthi Arahato kankhΠti ?

-îmantŒ.

- -Nanu vuttaµ BhagavatŒ－ “JŒnatvŒhaµ Bhikkhave passato ŒsavŒnaµ khayaµ vadŒmi, no ajŒnato no apassato. Ki? ca Bhikkhave jŒnato kiµ passato ŒsavŒnaµ khayo hoti ? Idaµ dukkhan ti Bhikkhave ajŒnato apassato ŒsavŒnaµ khayo hoti, ayaµ dukkhasamudayo ti jŒnato passato ŒsavŒnaµ khayo hoti, ayaµ dukkhanirodhagŒmin´pa ipadŒ ti jŒnato passato ŒsavŒnaµ khayo hoti. Evaµ kho Bhikkhave jŒnato evaµ passato ŒsavŒnaµ khayo hot´ti.” Atth’eva suttanto ti ?

-îmantŒ.

-Tena hi na vattabbaµ “Atthi Arahato kankhŒ ti”

 

17 Atthi Arahato kankhΠti ?